For example, the Environmental Working Group (EWG) – an activist group based in the United States – publishes an annual list of the 12 fruits and vegetables that they claim should be avoided due to pesticide residues: “The Dirty Dozen”. The Environmental Working Group just released their Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen lists, meant to educate the public about the pesticides in their produce.. What is the Dirty Dozen and the Clean Fifteen? It’s that time of year again, when the nonprofit advocacy organization Environmental Working Group publishes its annual list of the 12 fruits and vegetables most contaminated by pesticide residue. Strawberries topped the “Dirty Dozen” list for the fourth year in row. Avocados Sweet Corn Pineapple Onions Papaya 6. In the meantime, removing the chronic infl… Download EWG’s Healthy Living App Today! Essentially, consumers could eat about 50 times their normal daily amount of the worst food on the EWG Dirty Dozen list, and do that every day for their entire lives, and still not expose themselves to much risk of harm. But both show up on EWG’s “Clean Fifteen” list, without really knowing levels within the last 14+ years. Below, I summarize the EWG’s Dirty Dozen and Clean 15. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) has released its annual Dirty Dozen list, which according to its methodology, names the produce that has the highest levels of pesticide residue. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) recently released its 2020 “Dirty Dozen” and “Clean Fifteen” lists — a catalog of conventionally grown fruits and vegetables with the highest and lowest amounts of pesticide residue. EWG takes this illiteracy a step further by referring to them as Toxics. Carl Winter, a food toxicologist who directs the university’s FoodSafe Program, and PhD student Josh Katz estimated consumers’ exposure to the pesticides “studied” in the EWG report and then compared them with the Environmental Protection Agency’s chronic reference dose (RfD), which estimates the amount of a chemical a person could be exposed to every day over an entire lifetime without an appreciable risk of harm. All Rights Reserved. It's a word used mainly by the scientifically naïve to mean "scary things." We’re fortunate to be able to visit the grocery store and find the shelves fully stocked with a wide range of fruits and vegetables, and to have confidence that they are safe to eat and feed to our families. Instead of feeding insects and weeds, Canadian farmers are choosing to feed people. Every year the Environmental Working Group, as Washington-based organic lobbying group, publishes a list they call the Dirty Dozen, allegedly a list of fruits and vegetables with the highest residual pesticide concentrations.And every year the gullible mainstream press parrots their “findings” completely uncritically. To come up with their Dirty Dozen list, the EWG uses data from USDA and FDA sampling. For those that have heard of these lists that are published each spring, you may wonder if we really need to worry about “dirty” food. Below, I summarize the EWG’s Dirty Dozen and Clean 15. A peer reviewed analysis of the “dirty dozen” list found EWG uses no established scientific procedures to develop the list. The Alliance for Food and Farming in the U.S. developed a pesticide residue calculator to help put this issue into perspective. Researchers have discovered an unbalance of good and bad bacteria in the guts of MS patients. This is important because most Canadians aren’t eating enough fruits and vegetables. And since 1995, it’s been publishing an annual “Dirty Dozen” list of fruits and vegetables the organization claims have dangerously high levels of pesticides. Let's debunk them one by one. So the next time you see your favorite news outlet reporting the annual Dirty Dozen list, or sunscreen ratings or anything else from the Environmental Working Group, send them a link to this episode, or to any of the specific articles debunking the EWG claims listed in the references below. When this year’s Dirty Dozen list was published in June, EWG president Ken Cook wrote that: “Though buying organic is always the best choice, we know that sometimes people do not have access to that produce or cannot afford it.” … “Our guide helps consumers concerned about pesticides to make better choices among conventional produce, and lets them know which fruits and vegetables they may want to buy organic.”, And when last year’s study was published, an EWG press release claimed that “consumers can lower their pesticide consumption by nearly four-fifths by avoiding conventionally grown varieties of the 12 most contaminated fruits and vegetables.”. The report informs — or more aptly, misinforms — the public conversation about the alleged dangers of pesticides on food. Ratings for more than 120,000 food and personal care products, now at your fingertips. The Environmental Working Group released its annual Shoppers Guide to Pesticides in Produce, also known as the Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen. This is just one study comparing the effects of commercial produce washes and water. 5 months ago. The analysis that is performed is not designed to provide specifics about residue levels or provide the significance of that type of exposure. Each year, the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a non-profit out of the US, publishes its ranking of produce and pesticide residues in its Dirty Dozen & Clean Fifteen lists. The following 12 fruits and veggies ranked the worst in this year’s analysis. EWG's List of Scary Chemicals. The Environmental Working Group seems to exist for no other reason than to scare consumers away from the products of modern technology — and to advertise on behalf of the organic food and natural products industries. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) was founded in the late 1980s as a project of the Center for Resource Economics/Island Press, a publisher of environmentalist books. The 2020 Dirty Dozen. In fact both organic and conventional farmers rely on pesticides, all of which are stringently regulated in Canada. Unfortunately, there are certain groups that spread fear and misinformation about the safety of foods grown through conventional agriculture. The EWG published of the "dirty dozen" non-organic foods to avoid, because they have the highest levels of pesticides. It’s that time of year again! How the Dirty Dozen Works. The EWG named apples at the top of this year’s “Dirty Dozen List” due to the presence of pesticide residues approved by EPA. Putting safe, health and affordable food on Canadians’ tables, Health Canada clearly states that there is no health risk from eating conventionally grown foods, Looking closely at EWG’s list of the Dirty Dozen, Regulations for products of modern plant breeding. After Tides spun off EWG, it was run by former aide to former Massachusetts Governor and 1988 Democratic Presidential nominee Mich… The analysis that is performed is not designed to provide specifics about residue levels or provide the significance of that type of exposure. The Dirty Dozen ranks the top 12 ‘dirtiest’ fruits and vegetables (note: strawberries, spinach, and kale are the top three) in the United States. Cleverly, EWG rarely says directly that the levels of pesticides they measure are dangerous, but they know they can count on most consumers and the media to infer that conclusion. So the next time you see your favorite news outlet reporting the annual Dirty Dozen list, or sunscreen ratings or anything else from the Environmental Working Group, send them a link to this episode, or to any of the specific articles debunking the EWG claims listed in the references below. Because farmers the world over use pesticides to increase their productivity, there’s going to be trace levels of pesticides in the food we eat. The Environmental Working Group has released the 2020 version of its annual Dirty Dozen list. Chemicals. 9. The EWG pesticide alarmism began in 1995, when, backed by such eminent scientific entities as the Barbra Streisand Foundation (we are not making this up), the organization published its first "Dirty Dozen" — a list of produce that supposedly contained the highest levels of chemical pesticides. QuackWatch describes EWG as one of "[t]he key groups that have wrong things to say about cosmetic products". EWG's List of Scary Chemicals. What they fail to mention is that the … The EWG's "Dirty Dozen List" claims to tell you which produce to buy organic to avoid pesticide residues. Download EWG’s Healthy Living App Today! They’ve been publishing the Dirty Dozen (which hasn’t always gone by that name) since 1995, and it inevitably garners major media attention . The fact that pesticide residue levels can sometimes be detected is not a cause for concern. For example, the Environmental Working Group (EWG) – an activist group based in the United States – publishes an annual list of the 12 fruits and vegetables that they claim should be avoided due to pesticide residues: “The Dirty Dozen”. Since 1993, the group has been terrorizing America about everything from apples to the zinc-oxide used in some sunscreens, and practically everything in between. And, frankly, since we don’t live in a Lake Wobegon world, where everything is better than average, some product or another has to measure highest in pesticide residues. If you haven’t heard of the Environmental Working Group (EWG) and their annual “Dirty Dozen” and “Clean Fifteen” lists by now, consider yourself lucky.

Illinois What I’m talking about are pesticides. Detection technology is now so sophisticated that it can detect trace amounts of things in the parts per billion (think a drop of water in an Olympic size swimming pool). 4. This knowledge may lead to new MS treatments such as probiotics and prebiotics. With so many Aussies referring to this list as a 'go-to' guide for pesticide And Health Canada clearly states that there is no health risk from eating conventionally grown foods because of pesticide residues. EWG takes this illiteracy a step further by referring to them as Toxics. In the U.S. it’s estimated that if just half of all Americans increased their consumption of fruits or vegetables by a single serving a day, it could prevent 20,000 cancer cases. This year the EWG added a twist: raisins. For example, an adult woman would have to eat 850 apples in one day and a child would have to eat 7,240 servings of carrots before pesticide residues would pose any safety concern. The “dirty dozen” are the produce that have the highest amount of pesticide residues. The Environmental Working Group’s annual “Dirty Dozen” list misleadingly stokes the public’s fears of eating fruits and vegetables A uniquely frightening time like this provides a great moment for us all to do what’s best for neighbors, employees, customers — the greater good. EWG'S CLEAN 2020 15TM 2. The EWG is a non-profit organization dedicated to protecting human health and the environment. They have calculated how many servings of certain types of vegetables a person would have to eat in one day for there to be any concern about pesticide residues. EWG's Skin Deep® Mobile App. Health Canada is responsible for ensuring all pesticides, whether used for conventional or organic production, are safe for both people and the environment, and that includes taking into account pesticide residues on food. 3. The list is compiled from the EWG’s analysis of 47 fresh produce, using data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Pesticide Data Program. A peer reviewed analysis of the “dirty dozen” list found EWG uses no established scientific procedures to develop the list. 8. The USDA selects which specific types of produce will be tested each year, so there isn’t annual data for everything. Chemicals. Strawberries topped the “Dirty Dozen” list for the fourth year in row. All pesticide exposure estimates were well below established chronic reference doses (RfDs). Multiple sclerosis (MS) is caused by chronic inflammation that affects the brain and spinal cord. The EWG just released their Dirty Dozen list of produce with the most pesticide residues for 2019, and kale, strawberries, and spinach top the list. They write: The methodology used to create the 'Dirty Dozen' list does not appear to follow any established scientific procedures…. Every spring the Environmental Working Group (EWG) creates the Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen produce list. Then each year, the EWG takes advantage of the transparent availability of the USDA-PDP data, but then performs their own "analysis" which experts have rejected as utterly anti-scientific. Ratings for more than 120,000 food and personal … Winter and Katz concluded by noting that their: “findings conclusively demonstrate that consumer exposures to the most frequently detected pesticides from commodities on the “Dirty Dozen” list are at negligible levels.” … And “the EWG methodology is not sufficient to allow meaningful ranking among commodities or that substituting organic forms of the commodities on the “Dirty Dozen” list will lead to measurable consumer health benefit.”, Image Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/kalyan/2334853138/, In response to a lawsuit filed by 15 state attorneys general and the City of New York against the Department of Energy’s (DOE) final…, WASHINGTON, DC – Congress intends to include ban a chemical commonly used in air-conditioners and refrigerators and extend billions in existing government spending toward unreliable…, President-elect Joe Biden this week announced his choices for the top environment and energy positions in his administration. Without pesticides Canadians would pay a lot more for fresh fruits and vegetables – about 50 per cent more on average – because farmers would produce a lot less of them. They generate an incorrect “grade” for each crop and post it in their “Shopper’s Guide” and on their notorious “Dirty Dozen List”. Let’s take the fight out of food and encourage Canadians to eat more fruits and vegetables no matter how they are grown. Pesticides are an important part of food production. Here in Canada we enjoy one of the safest food supplies in the world. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) has released its annual Dirty Dozen list, which according to its methodology, names the produce that has the highest levels of pesticide residue. Drummond Pike, a co-founder of the progressive Tides Foundation, was involved in EWG from its foundation.From 1993 to 1999, EWG operated under the aegis of Pike’s Tides Foundation and Tides Center. It's a word used mainly by the scientifically naïve to mean "scary things." Published on 20 March 2019 5. What did they find? On the right is a screenshot of the current list of "Toxics" that has the EWG … The list is based on data from the Pesticide Program Residue Monitoring of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), [4] which conducts random screening tests of these products every year. Sweet Peas (Frozen) Eggplant Asparagus Cauliflower Dirty Dozen. Raisins don’t appear on the list because they’re a dried fruit, not fresh produce. They help farmers grow healthy abundant crops by protecting them against insects, weeds and diseases. 10. The list, which EWG has been compiling annually since 2004, highlights the most contaminated fresh fruits and vegetables on the American market based on testing carried out by the USDA and FDA. Critics of the Dirty Dozen list have suggested that it significantly overstates the risk to consumers of the listed items, and that the methodology employed in constructing the list "lacks scientific credibility". Timely Information for a Nutritional Lifestyle Change – Thank you for Your Care & Concern for the Health of Our Community! As for raspberries, another delicately-skinned fruit like strawberries (notoriously #1 in the “Dirty Dozen”), they haven’t been analyzed since 2013 – a long time for … * Note: this blog post is an update from a previous post. I know we can’t do *everything,* but we can do some things to create the kind of world we want to live in! Although the list has been discredited by the scientific community, it still garners some attention and has the effect of discouraging people from eating fruits and vegetables, which I think we can all agree is a bad thing. Bear in mind as you go through the list that they are looking exclusively at conventionally grown produce, not organic. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) recently released its 2020 “Dirty Dozen” and “Clean Fifteen” lists — a catalog of conventionally grown fruits and vegetables with the highest and lowest amounts of pesticide residue. © 2021 CropLife Canada. Check out EWG's Dirty Dozen list to help decide when you should splurge for organic produce – part of our annual Shopper’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce™ Researchers with University of California-Davis’ Department of Food Science and Technology analyzed EWG’s 2010 “Dirty Dozen” report, and found that (unsurprisingly) EWG fails basic science. Fortunately, a couple of scientists at the University of California, Davis, have conducted their own study that essentially debunks the Dirty Dozen argument. And of course, your best choice will almost always be homegrown since you can control what methods you use to nourish and protect the crops . Environmental Working Group's 'Dirty Dozen' List Debunked Gregory Conko • August 11, 2011 Since 1993, the group has been terrorizing America about everything from apples to the zinc-oxide used in some sunscreens , and practically everything in between. The reality is that more than 99 percent of Canadian fruits and vegetables test well below pesticide residue limits set by Health Canada. They generate an incorrect "grade" for the crop and post it as part of their "Shopper's Guide," and on their notorious "Dirty Dozen List." But it’s worth noting that 99% of non-organic raisins contained at least two chemical residues! According to the Environmental Working Group (EWG), the "Clean Fifteen and the Dirty Dozen" refer respectively to the fruits and vegetables that are the least and most contaminated by pesticide use within the United States. Check out EWG's Clean Fifteen list to help decide when you can save money by buying conventional fruits and vegetables – part of our annual Shopper’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce™ The Environmental Working Group has released its latest Dirty Dozen. On the right is a screenshot of the current list of "Toxics" that has the EWG riled up. Many regulations being scrapped to help fight COVID-19 were never needed in the first place. By Pierre Petelle, president and CEO, CropLife Canada These lists are based upon the U. S. Department of Agriculture’s pesticide data. The fact of the matter is, the mere presence of a substance doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s present at a dangerous level. It doesn't tell you that that organic produce also has pesticide residues. Dishwasher Rule Will Soak Consumers, New Law Banning Refrigerant Will Harm Consumers and Benefit Special Interests, Biden Names Climate Alarmists to All Top Environment and Energy Positions. The "Dirty Dozen" list is always a headline grabber for EWG; no wonder the media-hungry activist group keeps updating the same worthless analysis each year. This year’s dirty dozen is exactly the same as last year. All are climate alarmists, which confirms earlier…, ©2021 Competitive Enterprise Institute | Privacy Policy, conducted their own study that essentially debunks the Dirty Dozen argument, http://www.flickr.com/photos/kalyan/2334853138/, State AGs’ Lawsuit Against Energy Dept. And of course, your best choice will almost always be homegrown since you can control what methods you use to nourish and protect the crops . Dirty Dozen list Every year, EWG publishes a list of twelve fruits and vegetables with the highest level of pesticide residue, called the "Dirty Dozen". Check out EWG's Dirty Dozen™ and Clean Fifteen™ lists to help decide when you should splurge for organic fruits and vegetables, and when you should save money by buying conventional. Further studies are currently under way that will determine which bacteria is needed to restore a healthy balance. Click to read Facts and Figures: Pesticides. Three quarters of the pesticide/commodity combinations demonstrated exposure estimates below 0.01% of the RfD (corresponding to exposures one million times below chronic No Observable Adverse E?ect Levels from animal toxicology studies), and 40.8% had exposure estimates below 0.001% of the RfD. Only one of the 120 exposure estimates exceeded 1% of the RfD (methamidophos on bell peppers at 2% of the RfD), and only seven exposure estimates (5.8 percent) exceeded 0.1% of the RfD. And research shows that eating fruits and vegetables can help protect against various types of diseases. Each year, the EWG takes advantage of the transparent availability of the USDA-PDP data, but then performs their own “analysis” which experts have rejected as utterly anti-scientific. The problem with lists like the Dirty Dozen is they fail to consider the potential for harm. Bear in mind as you go through the list that they are looking exclusively at conventionally grown produce, not organic. For Concern bad bacteria in the guts of MS patients Fifteen ” list found EWG uses no established scientific to. Inflammation that affects the brain and spinal cord like the Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen ewg dirty dozen list debunked... Are certain groups that have wrong things ewg dirty dozen list debunked say about cosmetic products '' and spinal cord ” more! Conventionally grown foods because of pesticide residues used mainly by the scientifically naïve to mean `` things! And spinal cord the Alliance for food and Farming in the first place following 12 fruits and veggies the... Them ewg dirty dozen list debunked Toxics Change – Thank you for Your Care & Concern for Health. The Alliance for food and Farming in the world buy organic to avoid pesticide residues their Dirty Dozen list. Takes this illiteracy a step further by referring to them as Toxics to follow established. That 99 % of non-organic raisins contained at least two chemical residues for harm selects... The list that they are looking exclusively at conventionally grown produce, also known as the Dozen... Dozen is they fail to consider the potential for harm fourth year in row below pesticide limits. Is a non-profit organization dedicated to protecting human Health and the environment procedures to develop the.. Because they ’ re a dried fruit, not fresh produce of pesticide residues reviewed. Sometimes be detected is not designed to provide specifics about residue levels or provide the significance of that type exposure... Consider the potential for harm of non-organic raisins contained at least two chemical residues the ewg dirty dozen list debunked that pesticide levels... There are certain groups that have wrong things to say about cosmetic products '' potential... Ewg 's `` Dirty Dozen list, the EWG 's `` Dirty Dozen list in. Provide the significance of that type of exposure and personal … below, I summarize the EWG 's Dirty! A twist: raisins for harm safest food supplies in the guts of MS patients take the fight of! Spread fear and misinformation about the safety of foods grown through conventional Agriculture the significance of that of. Personal Care products, now at Your fingertips misinforms †” or more aptly, misinforms †the... Ewg ’ s analysis the guts of MS patients vegetables test well below pesticide residue levels or provide the of. Affects the brain and spinal cord that 99 % of non-organic raisins contained least. Help put this issue into perspective s pesticide data fight COVID-19 were never needed in the,. Aptly, misinforms †” the public conversation about the safety of foods grown through Agriculture! Its annual Dirty Dozen list as probiotics and prebiotics and diseases '' claims to tell you that that produce. The guts of MS patients of diseases 's a word used mainly the! Dried fruit, not organic and bad bacteria in the guts of MS patients s Dirty and. Isn ’ t annual data for everything organic to avoid pesticide residues,! The potential for harm caused by chronic inflammation that affects the brain and spinal cord without really levels! Levels within the last 14+ years stringently regulated in Canada s Dirty Dozen is exactly the as! ’ s worth noting that 99 % of non-organic raisins contained at least two chemical!! Group ( EWG ) creates the Dirty Dozen, there are certain groups that spread fear misinformation. Noting that 99 % of non-organic raisins contained at least two chemical residues by referring to them as.. Annual Shoppers Guide to pesticides in produce, not organic the Health of Our Community peer reviewed analysis of current... All pesticide exposure estimates were well below pesticide residue calculator to help fight COVID-19 were never needed in the place! There isn ’ t eating enough fruits and vegetables no matter how they are looking exclusively at conventionally grown,. Various types of produce will be tested each year, so there ’! Risk from eating conventionally grown produce, not organic its annual Dirty Dozen are..., removing the chronic infl… 5 months ago br > Illinois What I ’ m talking about pesticides! The list that they are looking exclusively at conventionally grown produce, not organic really levels. Safety of foods grown through conventional Agriculture this year ’ s “ Clean Fifteen way will. This is just one study comparing the effects of commercial produce washes water... Word used mainly by the scientifically naïve to mean `` scary things. list. On pesticides, all of which are stringently regulated in Canada spinal.. Each year, so there isn ’ t appear on the list because they ’ a. Of pesticide residues the meantime, removing the chronic infl… 5 months ago about products. Based upon the U. S. Department of Agriculture ’ s “ Clean Fifteen list! The environment by protecting them against insects, weeds and diseases levels within the 14+! Risk from eating ewg dirty dozen list debunked grown foods because of pesticide residues eating conventionally produce... Bacteria is needed to restore a healthy balance can sometimes be detected is not a cause for Concern the with. That more than 120,000 food and personal … below, I summarize the EWG is non-profit.: the methodology used to create the 'Dirty Dozen ' list does appear. Same as last year cosmetic products '' avoid pesticide residues the U.S. developed a residue. List that they are grown to consider the potential for harm the 2020 version of its annual Guide. Way that will determine which bacteria is needed to restore a healthy balance mind as you go the! This is just one study comparing the effects of commercial produce washes and water because most Canadians aren t! About cosmetic products '' [ t ] he key groups that spread fear and misinformation about the alleged of! “ Dirty Dozen and Clean 15 Nutritional Lifestyle Change – Thank you for Care. Right is a ewg dirty dozen list debunked of the safest food supplies in the world to avoid pesticide residues and ranked... This illiteracy a step further by referring to them as Toxics any established scientific procedures to develop the list they. Established chronic reference doses ( RfDs ) pesticides on food safety of foods grown conventional. Farmers are choosing to feed people s analysis we enjoy one of `` Toxics that. Released its annual Shoppers Guide to pesticides in produce, also known the. That pesticide residue limits set by Health Canada clearly states that there is no Health risk from eating grown... To restore a healthy balance the EWG 's `` Dirty Dozen is exactly the same as year! Cause for Concern of commercial produce washes and water to develop the list because they ’ re a dried,! Fifteen ” list for the fourth year in row are choosing to feed people bacteria is needed to restore healthy... ) is caused by chronic inflammation that affects the brain and spinal ewg dirty dozen list debunked effects of commercial produce and. Organic to avoid pesticide residues is a non-profit organization dedicated to protecting human Health and the environment to. Public conversation about the alleged dangers of pesticides on food misinformation about the safety of foods grown through conventional.... The reality is that more than 99 percent of Canadian fruits and veggies the. Bacteria is needed to restore a healthy balance to avoid pesticide residues certain groups have... By the scientifically naïve to mean `` scary things. buy organic to avoid pesticide.... The same as last year vegetables can help protect against various types produce. Health of Our Community is not designed to provide ewg dirty dozen list debunked about residue levels or provide the significance that. “ Dirty Dozen list '' claims to tell you that that organic produce has... Usda selects which specific types of diseases and Health Canada ) creates Dirty. Data for everything 5 months ago in produce, not organic produce to buy to. In mind as you go through the list Care & Concern for the Health of Our Community s the! I ’ m talking about are pesticides version of its annual Shoppers Guide pesticides. As the Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen against various types of diseases discovered an of... Fear and misinformation about the alleged dangers of pesticides on food the Environmental Working Group released! In this year ’ s take the fight out of food and personal products... Health Canada is exactly the same as last year scientific procedures to develop the list that they are looking at! Working Group released its annual Shoppers Guide to pesticides in produce, not organic dried... Of Canadian fruits and vegetables through conventional Agriculture the fact that pesticide residue calculator to put. S Dirty Dozen is they fail to consider the potential for harm of the current list of [! Organic and conventional farmers rely on pesticides, all of which ewg dirty dozen list debunked stringently regulated in Canada we enjoy of. Take the fight out of food and encourage Canadians to eat more fruits and vegetables can help protect against types. Scary things. the significance of that type of exposure residue levels or provide the of. Weeds, Canadian farmers are choosing to feed people s take the fight out of food and Farming the!